Showing posts with label US Shutdown. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US Shutdown. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

AFTER THE SHUTDOWN: THE DEBT CEILING

surowiecki-debt-ceiling.jpg
The U.S. markets had been closed for several hours when Congress, at midnight, let the government shut down, but, even so, they already reflected how things were going in Washington. Stocks were down, continuing a slow-motion slide that’s seen the S. & P. 500 drop on eight of the past nine days. It’s hardly been a momentous decline so far—the S. & P. has fallen about two and a half per cent from its all-time high, and is still up for the month—but it seems clear that markets are getting a little queasy about the shutdown.
Even if the shutdown is resolved, though, investors have a bigger concern on their minds: namely, the possibility that Republicans might actually refuse to raise the nation’s debt ceiling in a couple of weeks. The ceiling is the legal limit on the amount of money that the government is allowed to borrow, and raising it is necessary not just to keep the government running in the future but to allow it to pay for obligations it’s already incurred. As Justin Wolfers and Betsey Stevensonconvincingly showed last year, the 2011 imbroglio over the debt ceiling put a significant dent in both business and consumer confidence, held back hiring, and further weakened the recovery. It also sent the stock market tumbling—even though a debt-ceiling deal was eventually reached, the Dow fell almost fourteen per cent in less than a month during the crisis, in part because it made people realize that a U.S. default was no longer unthinkable. (It also led to the first downgrade of the U.S.’s credit rating in history.) So it’s hardly surprising that the standoff in Washington is spooking—if not yet terrifying—investors. Markets dislike uncertainty, and what the Republican hard-liners in the House of Representatives have done, most significantly, is to make the future look uncertain by suggesting that, if they do not get the concessions they want (above all, the repeal of Obamacare) they are willing to let the U.S. default.
What’s painful about this uncertainty, of course, is that it’s entirely self-inflicted. The U.S. has no trouble getting people to lend it money at eminently reasonable interest rates, so the only way we can default is if we simply choose not to pay our bills. And what’s really scary about it is that the concessions Republicans are asking for aren’t concessions that the Democrats can even consider, since they would turn the legislative process on its on head, allowing a minority of lawmakers to rewrite laws as they see fit.
The way you get a law passed (or repealed) in the U.S. is, after all, pretty well laid out in the Constitution: you need a majority in both houses of Congress, and you need a President who will sign the bill. If the President vetoes it, you need a supermajority to override the veto. Obamacare is the law of the land because it cleared these hurdles.
Now Republicans would like to repeal Obamacare. But they don’t have the votes. That’s the simple reality that all the talk about the unpopularity of Obamacare is meant to occlude: Republicans control only one house of Congress. In the past, that would have been enough to end the story. Republicans would have voted to repeal the law (as the House has done innumerable times already), failed to get repeal through the Senate, and moved on, biding their time and waiting for the day they took back the Senate and the Presidency. Self-evident as it sounds, that’s how democracy is supposed to work: you need a majority in order to change the law.
What the Republican hard-liners have decided instead is that even though they don’t have the necessary votes they should still get their way, and, in order to accomplish that, they’re going to hold the economic well-being of the country hostage. This is a radical and far-reaching demand, and acceding to it would in effect mean that controlling one house of Congress would be all you need to set policy. (Had congressional Democrats followed the Republican playbook in the nineteen-eighties, when they controlled the House but not the Senate, they would have demanded a repeal of the Reagan tax cuts in exchange for voting to raise the debt ceiling.)
There’s no obvious place where this process would stop, since there’s no distinct connection between Obamacare and the national debt. (At least the 2011 showdown was over fiscal issues.) Any law that hard-liners wanted to repeal (or pass), from abortion to gun control, could be pegged to a debt-ceiling vote. The ability to push through legislation would no longer be about which party was better at winning elections; it would be about which party was more willing to take the government, and with it the economy, over the cliff. Indeed, if the Republicans were to win this standoff, the result would be far more general uncertainty, since every debt-ceiling increase would become an occasion for rewriting laws.
This is why the Republican approach to the debt ceiling is not, as people like Zeke J. Miller, ofTime, have argued, the kind of hostage-taking that’s a “standard way of doing business in Washington.” This is really an attempt to remake the legislative process itself, and to do so by threatening to do something—default—that no one, including the people making the threat, believes to be in the best interest of the United States. We can’t be sure of exactly what would happen if the U.S. stopped paying its bills, but at the very least it would lead to havoc in the bond market and the financial system (which depends on U.S. Treasuries as risk-free collateral), higher interest rates, and an immediate hit to economic growth. It’s not a road that anyone should want to go down.
There’s no problem with House Republicans offering a bill that attaches the repeal of Obamacare to a debt-ceiling increase—as scholars have shown, many members of Congress have tried to attach unrelated provisions to debt-ceiling bills in the past. But when that bill fails to pass the Senate, as it will, the only responsible thing for the House to do is to then pass a clean bill raising the debt ceiling. It would be even better, as I argued in 2011, for Congress to just abolish the ceiling entirely, though that’s probably a bridge too far. Republicans may want a do-over on Obamacare, but risking economic catastrophe isn’t the way to get it.
Photograph: Scott Eells/Bloomberg via Getty.

3 Ways the Government Shutdown Affects the U.S. Economy

It’s official! For the first time since 1996, the U.S. government has been shut down. Is it the end of the world? Will the U.S. economy crash? Should I sell the dollar like there’s no tomorrow? Will the forex market shut down? What does the fox say?!
Now before y’all get ahead of yourselves and start panicking, let’s take a closer look at what caused this shutdown and what it implies for the U.S. economy.

The Cause

Stubborn U.S. lawmakers are mostly to blame for this mess, as the Republicans and Democrats refused to compromise. At the center of their arguments was the Affordable Care Act a.k.a. Obamacare, which House Republicans wanted to delay. Senate Democrats, however, kept rejecting the proposals being made.
You see, lawmakers have been pressured to come up with a plan to cut spending so that the U.S. can avoid reaching its debt ceiling and possibly defaulting on its debts. With lawmakers unable to agree on how to trim healthcare spending, the federal government is faced with no choice but to halt some of its non-essential operations.

The Effect

Now that we know who to blame for the government shutdown, let’s figure out what this means for the economy and the dollar:

1. Loss of income

As I mentioned in one of my previous articles, a government shutdown involves temporarily closing down some government agencies and services, which means that some people will not have jobs for a while.
In fact, about 800,000 federal civilian workers will be furloughed starting today. This includes workers in national parks and monuments, which spans everything from Yosemite to the Statue of Liberty. Imagine the loss of income as these workers will be sent home without pay indefinitely!
After crunching the numbers, analysts estimated that the shutdown can shave as much as 0.2% from the U.S. economic growth if it lasts for a few days. As seen in the past shutdown during the Clinton administration, a government shutdown that lasts a couple of weeks could eat up close to 1% of the GDP!

2. Shutdown of select financial services – No NFP this Friday!

Market junkies aren’t going to appreciate that the partial shutdown includes interruption in some key financial services. For example, the Internal Revenue Services (IRS) would stop answering phones and auditing taxpayers. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) would also stop handling registrations including IPOs. Sorry, guys. Guess you’ll have to wait longer for Twitter’s IPO offering.
What’s more important for many market players is that the Bureau of Labor Statistics won’t be releasing the all-important nonfarm payrolls (NFP) data during the shutdown. With Bernanke pegging the Fed’s next moves on future economic data, the loss of the employment numbers would make it even harder for the Fed to schedule their taper plans.

3. Higher risk of US credit d******

Forget the NFP report- we have bigger fish to fry! Investors around the world might not be happy with the government shutdown, but they’ll be as jumpy as kids on a sugar high if the government doesn’t raise its debt ceiling in less than two weeks.
A while back Treasury Secretary Jack Lew has estimated that the U.S. government would reach its current debt limit by no later than October 17. If the government doesn’t raise the ceiling by then, then Uncle Sam won’t have money to pay its creditors and have to DEFAULT.
This could knock down the U.S. credit rating from its AAA status and cause mayhem in major investors around the world. Take note that the U.S. hasn’t defaulted on its debts in… NEVER.

Credit: Piponomics

US shutdown: a guide for non-Americans

The American government has begun shutting its non-essential services. Why? And what will it mean?

US Capitol building
US shutdown: the Capitol in Washington DC, where Republicans control the lower house and Democrats control the Senate. Photograph: J Scott Applewhite/AP.

Please explain what just happened

The US government has begun shutting its non-essential services. Hundreds of thousands of workers are waking up to the news that they are on unpaid leave, and they don't know how long it will last. The shutdown, triggered at midnight Washington time, will bring a range of services to a standstill across the world's largest economy.

Why?

The Federal government had no choice. The US financial year ended on 30 September, and politicians on Capitol Hill have failed to agree a new budget for the 2013-2014 financial year. Even a 'stopgap' funding deal proved beyond them. Without a budget deal approved by both parts of Congress, the House of Representative and the Senate, there's no legal agreement to pay non-essential staff.

Weren't they supposed to fix this last night?

They tried. A series of proposals rattled between the two sides on Monday night until midnight struck without a deal.

Why couldn't they agree a deal?

Under the US constitution, the president cannot unilaterally bring in legislation. And despite weeks of talks, Republicans continue to include cuts and delays to Barack Obama's Affordable Care Act in the budget legislation they sent up to the Senate.
The House of Representatives is controlled by the Republican Party, whose Tea Party movement remain deeply opposed to Obamacare. They tried to use the budget as leverage to crowbar changes to the Act. The Senate, which is under the control of Obama's Democrats, has stood firm.

Will the shutdown mean the entire US government grinds to a halt?

No, it's not an anarchist's (or libertarian's?) dream. Essential services, such as social security and Medicare payments, will continue. 
The US military service will keep operating, and Obama signed emergency legislation on Monday night to keep paying staff. But hundreds of thousands of workers at non-essential services, from Pentagon employees to rangers in national parks, will be told to take an unpaid holiday.

So what happens how?

US politicians are meeting again in Washington on Tuesday. Before Monday's session broke up, the lower house proposed a 'bipartisan committee' to consider a way forward. The Senate is expected to reject this proposal, sticking to its position that Obamacare cannot be unravelled. Federal staff will remain unpaid until a budget is agreed. A 'stopgap' funding plan is an option, but Obama appeared wary of that option, arguing that would simply guarantee a repeated fight in a few weeks' time.

How much damage will it cause?

If people aren't getting paid, they won't spend as much in the shops. They may be unable to meet essential financial commitments, such as mortgages and credit card payments.
Analysts at IHS Global Insight have calculated that it will knock $300m a day off US economic output (total US nominal GDP, or output, was around $16 trillion last year).
The key issue is how long it lasts. Moody's Analytics reckons that a two-week shutdown would cut 0.3% off US GDP, while a month-long outage would knock a whole 1.4% off growth.

When did this last happen?

It's the first shutdown since 1995-1996, when Bill Clinton and the House of Representatives (and its speaker, Newt Gingrich) also failed to agree on a budget to fund federal services. That row ran for 28 days (over two stages).
But it was a more regular event in the 1980s, usually for a few days at a time. In total, the US government has partially shut down on 17 occasions before today.

Why doesn't it happen in other countries?

The shutdown situation is a product of the US democratic system. The president is both head of state and head of the federal government, without a guaranteed majority in either of the legislative bodies where new laws are debated and voted upon (because presidents, congressmen and women and senators are elected separately). The president can't simply ram laws through Capitol Hill.
In Britain, for example, tax and spending policies are outlined in the budget, presented to parliament by the chancellor of the exchequer. These changes are brought into law in a finance bill in the House of Commons. That's in effect a confidence vote in the government, and even the most fractious backbench MP would balk at rebelling on it.
Finance bills are also one area where the elected House of Commons has the upper hand over the unelected House of Lords. The Lords have no power to reject a money bill; they can only delay it for a month.

How does the US shutdown row tie in with the debt ceiling battle?

They are separate issues, but the shutdown is raising fears over the debt ceiling.
America has a legal limit on its borrowing of $16.7tn dollars, and it's likely to hit that point in mid-October.
If a deal isn't reached, then America would run out of borrowing room, meaning the world's biggest economy would default on its debts. Both problems need solving – and a shutdown is now eating into valuable time to fix the debt ceiling.

Why can't they just raise the debt ceiling?

Again, legislation is needed. Republicans are again trying to link the plan to Obamacare – arguing that the healthcare reforms are unaffordable.

How are the markets reacting?

So far, there's no panic. Investors are calculating that the shutdown will be short. But prepare for nervousness as that debt ceiling deadline gets closer.
The dollar, though, is being hit – dropping half a cent against major currencies.
Credit: Graeme Wearden